Are you a leader or a manager?

Are you a leader or a manager?

William Shah

October 10, 2022

The distinction between a leader and a manager may be summarized as follows: leaders motivate, and managers control. Managers often focus on coordinating and carrying out duties, whereas leaders focus on motivating and encouraging their people to achieve common goals. Which one are you?

Interestingly enough, every leader has probably filled the job of manager at some point. But not every manager has proven to be an effective leader. This is because managerial positions are often filled by volunteers when a vacancy arises in your company. Any manager who can provide for such requirements will do well. A leader, on the other hand, calls for a distinct set of skills that might arise at any time throughout an organization's development; in fact, a leader doesn't even require a special title.

In this section, I will outline the main distinctions.


Differences between Having a Vision and Actually Carrying It Out

You have the duty to provide direction as a leader. This is to say, the capacity to think ahead of where you are right now and create a future that exceeds all your wildest dreams. Meanwhile, a manager's attention will be on carrying out that vision and identifying the essential processes that will bring it to fruition. Managers tend to break down these goals into smaller, more manageable tasks, whereas leaders can grasp the broad picture and craft a strategy to get there.


Differences Between Individuals and Organizational Systems

Leaders are concerned with the welfare of their followers, whereas managers are more concerned with the smooth functioning of their departments. Leaders serve as role models for the individuals they oversee, providing them with encouragement and direction. They put forth considerable effort to learn about the interests and motivations of their staff to achieve this goal. Ultimately, that's what will determine the company's fate. Managers consider the procedures that will yield the required results in light of the company's goals. As a side note, they do pay some attention to the people, although it is usually not their major focus.


Leadership vs. Management Abilities

Soft skills are more fundamental to leadership than hard or technical ones are to management. Leadership often requires the ability to make decisions, communicate effectively, create rapport, and think strategically.

The competencies of an excellent manager include:

  • Arranging expenditures and income

  • Disposal of Duties

  • Creativity

  • Problem-solving


Leadership vs. Management Characteristics

Being a leader or manager means establishing a course of action and inspiring others to pursue it. Leaders, on the other hand, are more concerned with the future than managers are. Leaders, like managers, need to be able to establish rapport with their staff, but managers may not require quite as strong of bonds given their concentration on getting things done.

Leaders exhibit traits such as:

  • The process of discovering and developing exceptional ability.

  • Attempting to break new ground in terms of what is feasible.

  • Putting one's eggs in one basket.

  • Promoting the welfare of one's workforce.

On the contrary, there are a few consistent features of good management that include:

  • Holding the line on the current situation.

  • Finding inefficiencies and fixing them.

  • Taking precautions.

  • Doing what has to be done.


Leadership vs. Management Examples

Take the role of a project manager for a marketing firm.

Overseeing client projects, distributing work to colleagues, and checking in on their progress toward deadlines are all examples of what you may do on a typical day on the job. Meanwhile, the business owner may be concerned with things like customer acquisition, long-term planning, and network development. The abilities and duties of both positions are similar. But they have quite different priorities.

Too much long-term planning prevents you from understanding what it will take today to get there. If you have a short-term outlook, you won't have the larger picture to guide your efforts.

Leadership is supposedly superior to management, as this is how it is usually portrayed. The fact is that both are essential to the success of any business. Which one are you?